It's great
to see a reality show where the feuding contestants can
just punch one another in the face. Who hasn't watched Survivor
or American Idol or The Apprentice
thinking a hard right uppercut might occasionally be an
appropriate challenge?
In fact, the physical beatings are what give NBC's The
Contender more authenticity than competitions to see
which fashion model can stomach the most weasel
entrails. The show, which premiered Monday and airs its
second episode at 10 tonight before moving to 8 p.m.
Sundays, takes 16 middleweight boxers and has them do
what they do: fight - in this case for a $1 million
prize.
We get to know the boxers through melodramatic
vignettes about their families and lives and struggles.
Then we cheer as they try to hurt each other. Each
episode ends in one battle between two contenders. The
loser is off the show.
Of course, all the boxers, and the families who
lovingly support them in the show, were screen-tested
and chosen for their looks, their character types, and
gripping back stories. And yes, the climactic fights are
edited and scored with music, as if they were movie
scenes.
But the bruises - and the lives these guys have built
around the brutal sport - are real. This is the show
that includes Najai Turpin, billed as "a tough,
punching street kid from Philadelphia fighting for a
better life for his family." His story is too real.
In the early hours of Valentine's Day in West Philly,
months after the series was taped, Turpin committed
suicide.
"The episode in which he was most depicted will
stand as a wonderful testament to who he was," an
NBC statement said. "It will not be changed."
The network won't say which episode that will be.
Boxing is experiencing one of its periodic revivals. Million
Dollar Baby won the best-picture Oscar by showing
how magnificent and horrible a sport it can be. Russell
Crowe plays '30s champ Jim Braddock in Cinderella Man,
coming later this year.
The Contender could be a further coup for a
sport that hasn't been in network prime time regularly
since the mid-1970s. That was when Muhammad Ali was
still punching, Sugar Ray Leonard and his fellow 1976
Olympic champs were heroes, and Rocky won its own
Oscar.
Because boxers often come with pathos and conflict,
it's no surprise so much drama has been built around
them (Raging Bull, On the Waterfront, The Great White
Hope, Requiem for a Heavyweight, The Harder They Fall,
Somebody Up There Likes Me, Body and Soul). Last
year, four or five treatments for boxing-based reality
shows floated around Hollywood. Fox produced one last
fall, in partnership with boxer Oscar de la Hoya. After
a few swings in prime time, it got kicked to cable.
The Contender comes from Mark Burnett, whose Survivor
and The Apprentice have defined the slickly
produced fake voyeurism that reality viewers love.
Burnett is joined by movie producer Jeffrey Katzenberg
as well as Leonard and Rocky creator Sylvester
Stallone, who act as sort of good-Trump/bad-Trump
cohosts.
They probably wished for Trumpier ratings. The
premiere drew an estimated 8.1 million viewers from 9:30
to 11 p.m., according to Nielsen Media Research. That's
far short of the 15.1 million NBC's Medium has
averaged in the 10 p.m. slot. CBS finished first from
9:30 to 11 as Two and a Half Men got 17.4 million
and CSI: Miami had 21.7 million.
Give the producers credit for using legitimate
fighters instead of ringers. Jonathan Reid, according to
Stallone's voiceover, is "a seasoned pro with a
checkered past" and a 33-1 record. Reid once fought
a guy who has fought middleweight champion Bernard
Hopkins. We meet Alfonso Gomez, "an unknown
Mexican-born fighter just trying to prove he
belongs," and Anthony Bonsante, "a single dad
whose career has been all about providing for his
children."
Of course, it's still network TV, so the boxers are
split into teams for silly games that determine who
fights whom. No personality conflict or contender's fear
of disappointing family members is left undocumented.
Fight scenes are backed by music reminiscent of Rocky,
with strings and horns conveying heroism and a
time-running-out timpani banging down the seconds. (Katzenberg
hired composer Hans Zimmer, whose extensive movie work
includes Gladiator.) Conspicuously absent is an
on-screen clock timing rounds; there's no way to know
how much the action has been edited.
Still, even in this staged arena, we get what thrills
and repulses us about boxing: two desperate people
trying to hurt each other for the entertainment of the
crowd.
At the end of the first episode, after losing in an
upset to Gomez, Peter Manfredo Jr. appears with his face
busted up. "I feel like I let everybody down, not
just myself, but my wife, my father, my daughter,"
he says. "All's I can hear is my father in my
head." And the show just ends.
Expect similar "coulda been a contender"
regrets to conclude every episode. It's contrived and
manipulative, sure. But nobody has to say, "You're
fired."