A judge's
ruling Wednesday in a dispute between Fox's "The
Next Great Champ" and a rival boxing program
favored Fox. But round two is set for next month.
Superior Court Judge Linda Lefkowitz denied a request
from producers of NBC's "The Contender" for a
temporary restraining order against the Fox reality
series produced by boxer Oscar De La Hoya and Endemol
USA.
DreamWorks SKG and reality mogul Mark Burnett, makers
of "The Contender," are trying to force Fox to
edit allegedly unlawful bouts out of "The Next
Great Champ" before it airs Sept. 10.
Fox should be barred from using "film of any
boxing match that wasn't legally promoted,"
DreamWorks said Wednesday, citing a California Athletic
Commission report on the reality series.
The commission is responsible for licensing and
regulating boxing promoters. The judge ruled that
preventing Endemol from delivering filmed material to
Fox would be "tantamount to a direct prior
restraint."
She agreed, however, to set a Sept. 8 hearing on a
preliminary injunction. Fox called the ruling as "a
significant victory."
"As the producers of `The Contender' well know,
the California Athletic Commission has not made any
findings or rulings. This is yet another in a series of
never-ending attempts by 'The Contender's' producers to
stifle competition," the network said.
The commission, which issued a memorandum raising
questions about aspects of the series' fights, recently
postponed a hearing on the matter. DreamWorks took heart
in the judge's ruling.
"It's a strong statement by the court that they
understand the gravity and legitimacy of the concerns
raised by the state Athletic Commission, and both
parties now will have the opportunity" to make
their case, said DreamWorks spokesman Andy Spahn.
DreamWorks and Burnett allege that "The Next
Great Champ" was produced on a "rushed and
frenzied basis" to beat NBC's series to the air.
Although "The Contender" was announced first,
it's not airing until sometime in November.
In "The Next Great Champ," aspiring boxers
compete for a contract with De La Hoya's company and a
World Boxing Organization title fight. In "The
Contender," the prize is $1 million and a shot at a
boxing career.
NBC and Fox already have sparred outside court over
the competing reality TV concepts.
NBC Universal Television Group President Jeff Zucker
accused Fox of hijacking the boxing idea after NBC
announced it planned a series with DreamWorks' founder
Jeffrey Katzenberg, Burnett and Sylvester Stallone of
"Rocky" fame.
Fox TV entertainment chief Gail Berman said claims
that Fox is stealing reality show concepts are
"outrageous" and a business ploy.